Getting SSDI for Post

Getting SSDI for Post-Polio Sequelae.
Dr. Richard L. Bruno
Chairperson, International Post-Polio Task Force
Director, The Post-Polio Institute
The International Centre for Post-Polio Education and Research
Englewood (NJ) Hospital and Medical Center, USA
Toll Free: 877-POST-POLIO; (201) 894-3724
E-Mail: postpolioinfo@AOL.COM

I had polio in 1952 and one leg has always been in a long leg brace. I am a computer analyst and now have severe fatigue. I fall asleep at my computer. But from what I read on the Internet, everyone who had polio gets denied for Social Security Disability, even when they hire a lawyer and appeal the denials. Either I will get fired or I just wont be able get out of bed and go to work. I have no choice but to keep working.

You do have a choice! It is not true that it is Social Security Administration (SSA) policy to deny Social Security Disability Income (SSDI) payments to polio survivors. In 1985 we wrote the document that allows polio survivors to get SSDI, called the POMS for Evaluation of the Late Effects of Poliomyelitis (24580.010). In 1987, we worked with Senator Bill Bradley to force SSA to release the POMS, which is when polio survivors started getting SSDI. What's more, in March, 2001, SSA the SSA Commissioner agreed to our request to convert the POMS into what is called a "Social Security Ruling" that binds adjudicators and administrative law judges decisions about disability for polio survivors. The Social Security Ruling, SSR 03-1p.; Titles II and XVI: Development and Evaluation of Disability Claims Involving Postpolio Sequelae, was released on July 2, 2003. SSA has also agreed to "retrain" SSA personnel to properly review polio survivors' applications for SSDI."The Ruling is more inclusive than the POMS and uses the term "Postpolio Sequelae" to describe all of the late-onset symptoms polio survivors experience, not only post-polio syndrome -- new muscle weakness in those who had paralytic polio -- but also 'early advanced degenerative arthritis, sleep disorders, respiratory insufficiency, and a variety of mental disorders (having) an etiological link to either the acute polio infection or to chronic deficits resulting from the acute infection." According to the Ruling "any one or a combination of these disorders...will constitute the presence of 'postpolio sequelae' and can be grounds for granting SSDI.

For the first time sleep disorders, 'problems with attention, reduced concentration capacity, inability to persist in tasks, or memory problems' are recognized as causes of disability. The Ruling also recognizes The Post-Polio Institute's research on the psychological effects of polio and PPS, that "traumatic psychological experiences associated with acute polio infection are revived when polio survivors recognize the onset of further weakness and functional loss. Many polio survivors endured a life- threatening infection as young children. They may have spent extended periods away from their homes and families while hospitalized with paralysis or respiratory dysfunction, or while undergoing multiple orthopedic surgeries. Often they endured many months, or sometimes years, of hospitalization and rehabilitation. The psychological effect of perceiving the onset of further weakness, fatigue, respiratory dysfunction or joint pain, many years following the acute infection, can be significant," and lead to disabling "anxiety and depression...mood changes and social withdrawal." Any of these symptoms can be the cause of inability to work and grounds for granting SSDI.

The Ruling also recognizes that "many individuals with medically severe polio residuals have worked despite their limitations." The Ruling states that "the new onset of further physical or mental impairments (even though they may appear to be relatively minor) in polio survivors may result in further functional problems that can limit or prevent their ability to continue work activity. Postpolio sequelae may effectively alter the ability of these individuals to continue functioning at the same level they maintained for years following their initial polio infection.'"

So, SSA can and does grant SSDI for polio survivors. What's more not one of our patients has ever been denied SSDI. Why? It's all in the details And you don't need a lawyer to get SSDI:

Read and print the Social Security Ruling for Post-Polio Sequelae
Read and print the following letters to SSA: Letter 1, Letter 2.
Ask the Social Security Administration office to mail you the SSDI application form (SSA-3368-BK). Tell the SSA office you can't come in to pick up or fill out the forms because you "physically can't" make the trip.
There is usually a phone interview before or just after you get the forms. This is not a big deal. SSA just wants to briefly hear why you think you're disabled and collect general information. But get the name, phone number and address of the adjudicator working on your case, the head of that local SSA office and the head of the office where your case will be decided. You will be asking your Congress people to write to these individuals.
Before the phone interview and before you fill out the application form, make a list of work-related disabilities and symptoms. On one side of a piece of paper list the things you can't do that are job related (e.g., can't stay awake at your desk, can't focus attention, have to read the same paragraph over and over, can't lift or stand or carry). Then, on the other side of the page list the SPECIFIC symptoms that prevent you from doing the job related activities. Use the wording in the Social Security Ruling (e.g., "I can't focus attention because of severe fatigue; I can't stand for more than 5 minutes because of left leg muscle weakness; I can't walk for more than half a block because of loss of endurance"). Mention the number of time you have fallen and if falls have increased in the past year (Falls or "being unsafe" on your feet are required for Medicare to pay for PPS treatment. Medicare starts two years after you get SSDI). Mention times you almost fell asleep while driving. Be brief and clear in describing the symptoms and limitation. Remember: For every work- related problem, describe the symptom that disables you; for every symptom, tell what task it prevents you from doing.
Do illnesses, injuries or conditions" limit you ability to work? This is the only thing SSA wants to know. Avoid the kitchen sink approach. Don't list everything that has ever happened to you, polio-related or not. Limit your answers to illnesses, injuries or conditions" that limit your ability to work. The Ruling says "old records are not required," so you don't have to have records of childhood surgeries or even hospitalizations for polio. Also, do not include records of illness or hospitalizations you have had as an adult unless you have a condition that also limits your ability to work. If you are not disabled from work by allergies, an ulcer, a hip replacement, high blood pressure, osteoporosis, successfully treated sleep apnea, a heart attack -- even a heart transplant -- do not list those diagnoses, the medications you take for them, hospitals where you were treated, or the doctors you saw for them. Don't even list blood tests or X-rays you've had unless they directly relate to the "illnesses, injuries or conditions" that limit your ability to work. SSA reviewers will sometimes look at the first doctor's report -- maybe a note from your GP of 5 years ago -- that says "Had allergy shot. No other problems" and deny you SSDI for PPS because you have no disabling symptoms. If you have "illnesses, injuries or conditions" that do not limit your ability to work, SSA doesn't need to know about them. The more doctors and conditions and tests you list, the more likely it is that SSA will not even get all the reports, making the process take longer
than it needs to. The best thing you can do is list only one doctor -- your PPS doctor -- who knows about PPS and will write clear reports about your inability to work due to specific PPS symptoms referring to the symptoms described in the Ruling. Your doctor need to read the Ruling before writing the report for SSA.
However, if you have PPS and then had a heart attack, and you now have limited stamina because of PPS and because your heart is not pumping enough blood, you have two conditions that together disable you from working. In this case, list your PPS doctor and your heart doctor. You can have several conditions that add together to cause a work disability. Also, it is important that each doctor write a report to SSA describing the your PPS symptoms and the impairments they cause. The report should also include the severity of any residual weakness, as well as the onset, pattern, and severity of any new physical or mental deficits. A description of current functional limitations and restrictions on physical and mental activity should be included.
List home related limitations in the same way as work limitations, e.g., "I can no longer do laundry, shop, cook, yard work, because of fatigue and muscle weakness. Now my husband/wife/children have to do these jobs." SSA wants to make sure you are limited on the job and at home.
Use the "In spite of..." argument. Mention assistive devices you use, especially new ones, and that you still can't work "in spite of" using these devices, making necessary changes at home and getting reasonable accommodation at work (e.g., "In spite of getting a long leg brace that I was able to discard
when I was 10 years old, using a wheelchair for the first time in my life, getting a stair-glide in my house, and sleeping for 30 minutes at lunch, leaving work early every day, my fatigue is still increasing and I fall asleep at my desk ").
Again, use symptoms described in the Ruling. If you work at a desk, brain fatigue will likely be the cause of your work disability. If you do physical work or type at a computer, physical fatigue, loss of endurance, or specific leg, arm, hand or muscle weakness may be the cause of your work disability. Stay away from mentioning any type of pain, especially back pain. It usually doesn't help to mention joint or muscle pain even when it is caused by work-related duties or is associated with muscle weakness, because it is almost impossible to get SSDI due to pain. Also, never mention depression, anxiety or medications you take for them unless these symptoms prevent you from working. Depression is an automatic rejection unless you live in a mental hospital.
In the "Remarks" section at the end of the application, briefly summarize your answers and describe your work disability as caused by your specific PPS symptoms, again linking each work limitation to a given symptom and using the wording in they Ruling. Also, mention long-standing polio "disabilities" that are not problems. SSA decides that you are work disabled based on your age, levels of skill and schooling. If you load trucks and graduated from the 8th grade, SSA won't expect you to go to college to get "sedentary" career. But, if your are a college grad and have trouble walking, SSA will say you have the education and skills to do something that doesn't require walking. Some people with severe fatigue, but who have always used a leg brace, have been denied SSDI because SSA said, " Your leg has always been paralyzed and should not affect your working at a desk job." You should say something like, "The fact that I have always used a long leg brace and that my arm has always been weak has nothing to do with my disabling post-polio fatigue today."
The Ruling states that polio survivors' description of symptoms and limitations to their own physicians and psychologists are the primary factors when it comes diagnosing PPS and inability to work. An EMG and functional capacity evaluation have been removed from the evaluation process for PPS. The Ruling also states that only in "select cases, where severity of the impairment is unclear, an examination by a physician or psychologist who is knowledgeable about polio and postpolio sequelae is appropriate, if such a specialist is available." SSA can ask for what's called a "Consultative Examination" if there is not enough information in you're doctor's reports to determine if you are work disabled. However, many polio survivors find SSA sending them for a consultative examination to a neurologist -- or even a psychiatrist -- who knows nothing about PPS. SSA policy states that your treating doctor is the "preferred source" for the consultative examination, unless your doctor's records contain "conflicts or inconsistencies" or "prior experience indicates that the treating (doctor) is not a productive source of clear information." You have the right, and SSA regulations require, that you to go back to your own doctor for a consultative examination.
You took the time to vote, so put that vote to use. SSA gets very careful when they know your Senators and Congressperson are watching over their shoulder. Send a letter like this and attach the Social Security Ruling:

__________________________________________________________________
Dear Senator and Congressperson:

I am a polio survivor of the 19XX epidemic. I have been working for XX years as a YOUR JOB but am now unable to work because of Post-Polio Syndrome (PPS).

Many polio survivors are being denied SSDI because SSA personnel do not know there has been a policy in place since 1987 -- the POMS for the "The Late Effects of Poliomyelitis" (24580.01) -- allowing polio survivors to receive disability benefits. SSA adjudicators wrongly use the listing for "Acute Anterior Poliomyelitis" ( 11.11) to determine eligibility for SSDI for those with Post-Polio Sequelae. Polio survivors are now disabled, not by polio paralysis or "motor disorganization, but most commonly by disabling fatigue due to Post-Polio Sequelae. To insure that SSA personnel no longer inappropriately deny polio survivors, a Social Security Ruling for Post-Polio Sequelae (Social Security Ruling, SSR 03-1p.; Titles II and XVI) was released by Commissioner Barnhart on
July 2, 2003 (please see enclosed).

Would you please contact the SSA ADJUDICATOR'S NAME and HEAD OF THE SSA OFFICE at the YOUR TOWN Social Security office, 555-555-5555, at THIS ADDRESS. Please ask them to consult the Social Security Ruling for Post-Polio Sequelae and make a decision about my disability based on the Ruling, SSA's own procedures
and guidelines, and on the actual cause of my not being able to work, LIST CAUSE(S).

Yours truly,
__________________________________________________________________
Include copies of your letters to the Congressperson and the Social Security Ruling with your application. Call your adjudicator at the SSA office about once a month to see where things stand. It takes about 6 months for you to get your first check.

Since it's the government mistakes do happen and you may get denied. If you are denied, read the reason for denial, which may be because of the adjudicator's not having read or misreading the Social Security Ruling. Find out the specific reason for the denial. Then do two things. FIRST, ask your Congressperson and Senators to ask for an Administrative Review of your denial to determine if the guidelines in the Social Security Ruling were followed and the latest policies about PPS were applied. Write your Senators and Congressperson:

__________________________________________________________________
Dear Senator/Congressperson:

I am a polio survivor of the 19XX epidemic. I have been working for XX years as a YOUR JOB but am now unable to work because of Post-Polio Sequelae (PPS). But I have been denied SSDI.

Many polio survivors are being denied SSDI because SSA personnel do not know there has been a policy in place since 1987 -- the POMS for the "The Late Effects of Poliomyelitis" (24580.01) -- allowing polio survivors to receive disability benefits. SSA adjudicators wrongly use the listing for "Acute Anterior Poliomyelitis" ( 11.11) to determine eligibility for SSDI for those with Post-Polio Sequelae. Polio survivors are now disabled, not by polio paralysis or "motor disorganization, but most commonly by disabling fatigue due to Post-Polio Sequelae. To insure that SSA personnel no longer inappropriately deny polio survivors, a Social Security Ruling for Post-Polio Sequelae (Social Security Ruling, SSR 03-1p.; Titles II and XVI) was released by Commissioner Barnhart on
July 2, 2003 (please see enclosed).

Would you please contact the SSA ADJUDICATOR'S NAME and HEAD OF THE SSA OFFICE at the YOUR TOWN Social Security office, 555-555-5555, at THIS ADDRESS. As a Member of Congress you can ask for an Administrative Review of my denial to determine if the Social Security Ruling was followed. Please ask for an
Administrative Review and ask Social Security to make a decision about my disability based on the Social Security Ruling, their own procedures and guidelines, and on the actual cause of my not being able to work, LIST CAUSE(S).

Yours truly,
________________________________________________________________
Send copies of your SSDI application, denial notice from SSA, the letters posted here from SSA and the Social Security Ruling to your Congressperson and Senators.

If you cannot get or are not successful with an Administrative Review appeal immediately. Discuss with your doctor the specific reason for the denial and asking him/her to also write a letter to SSA. You have a right to two local appeals and then a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). The ALJ's ruling can be appealed as well. If you follow this procedure, you won't need a lawyer even for the appeal. About 90% of the cases that come before the ALJs have their denials overturned, so there is a light at the end of the tunnel.

But, if you are denied at any stage you can choose to file a NEW application for SSDI. It will be as if the first application and denial(s) didn't happen. However you just have to find out your "last insured date." SSA only goes back 17 months from the filing date to establish the onset of disability and retroactive benefits. The money you get is based on the past 17 month of earnings. So if you file a new application and have been out of work for a while you will get less in SSDI benefits.

Applying for SSDI can be a kind of "game" that you can win if you follow the rules!

GOOD LUCK!

Be well,

Dr. Richard L. Bruno

.
Dr. Richard L. Bruno
Chairperson, International Post-Polio Task Force
Director, The Post-Polio Institute
The International Centre for Post-Polio Education and Research
Englewood (NJ) Hospital and Medical Center, USA
Toll Free: 877-POST-POLIO; (201) 894-3724
E-Mail: postpolioinfo@AOL.COM

Read and print the Social Security Ruling for Post-Polio Sequelae
Read and print the following letters to SSA: Letter 1, Letter 2.
Ask the Social Security Administration office to mail you the SSDI application form (SSA-3368-BK). Tell the SSA office you can't come in to pick up or fill out the forms because you "physically can't" make the trip.
There is usually a phone interview before or just after you get the forms. This is not a big deal. SSA just wants to briefly hear why you think you're disabled and collect general information. But get the name, phone number and address of the adjudicator working on your case, the head of that local SSA office and the head of the office where your case will be decided. You will be asking your Congress people to write to these individuals.
Before the phone interview and before you fill out the application form, make a list of work-related disabilities and symptoms. On one side of a piece of paper list the things you can't do that are job related (e.g., can't stay awake at your desk, can't focus attention, have to read the same paragraph over and over, can't lift or stand or carry). Then, on the other side of the page list the SPECIFIC symptoms that prevent you from doing the job related activities. Use the wording in the Social Security Ruling (e.g., "I can't focus attention because of severe fatigue; I can't stand for more than 5 minutes because of left leg muscle weakness; I can't walk for more than half a block because of loss of endurance"). Mention the number of time you have fallen and if falls have increased in the past year (Falls or "being unsafe" on your feet are required for Medicare to pay for PPS treatment. Medicare starts two years after you get SSDI). Mention times you almost fell asleep while driving. Be brief and clear in describing the symptoms and limitation. Remember: For every work- related problem, describe the symptom that disables you; for every symptom, tell what task it prevents you from doing.
Do illnesses, injuries or conditions" limit you ability to work? This is the only thing SSA wants to know. Avoid the kitchen sink approach. Don't list everything that has ever happened to you, polio-related or not. Limit your answers to illnesses, injuries or conditions" that limit your ability to work. The Ruling says "old records are not required," so you don't have to have records of childhood surgeries or even hospitalizations for polio. Also, do not include records of illness or hospitalizations you have had as an adult unless you have a condition that also limits your ability to work. If you are not disabled from work by allergies, an ulcer, a hip replacement, high blood pressure, osteoporosis, successfully treated sleep apnea, a heart attack -- even a heart transplant -- do not list those diagnoses, the medications you take for them, hospitals where you were treated, or the doctors you saw for them. Don't even list blood tests or X-rays you've had unless they directly relate to the "illnesses, injuries or conditions" that limit your ability to work. SSA reviewers will sometimes look at the first doctor's report -- maybe a note from your GP of 5 years ago -- that says "Had allergy shot. No other problems" and deny you SSDI for PPS because you have no disabling symptoms. If you have "illnesses, injuries or conditions" that do not limit your ability to work, SSA doesn't need to know about them. The more doctors and conditions and tests you list, the more likely it is that SSA will not even get all the reports, making the process take longer
than it needs to. The best thing you can do is list only one doctor -- your PPS doctor -- who knows about PPS and will write clear reports about your inability to work due to specific PPS symptoms referring to the symptoms described in the Ruling. Your doctor need to read the Ruling before writing the report for SSA.
However, if you have PPS and then had a heart attack, and you now have limited stamina because of PPS and because your heart is not pumping enough blood, you have two conditions that together disable you from working. In this case, list your PPS doctor and your heart doctor. You can have several conditions that add together to cause a work disability. Also, it is important that each doctor write a report to SSA describing the your PPS symptoms and the impairments they cause. The report should also include the severity of any residual weakness, as well as the onset, pattern, and severity of any new physical or mental deficits. A description of current functional limitations and restrictions on physical and mental activity should be included.
List home related limitations in the same way as work limitations, e.g., "I can no longer do laundry, shop, cook, yard work, because of fatigue and muscle weakness. Now my husband/wife/children have to do these jobs." SSA wants to make sure you are limited on the job and at home.
Use the "In spite of..." argument. Mention assistive devices you use, especially new ones, and that you still can't work "in spite of" using these devices, making necessary changes at home and getting reasonable accommodation at work (e.g., "In spite of getting a long leg brace that I was able to discard
when I was 10 years old, using a wheelchair for the first time in my life, getting a stair-glide in my house, and sleeping for 30 minutes at lunch, leaving work early every day, my fatigue is still increasing and I fall asleep at my desk ").
Again, use symptoms described in the Ruling. If you work at a desk, brain fatigue will likely be the cause of your work disability. If you do physical work or type at a computer, physical fatigue, loss of endurance, or specific leg, arm, hand or muscle weakness may be the cause of your work disability. Stay away from mentioning any type of pain, especially back pain. It usually doesn't help to mention joint or muscle pain even when it is caused by work-related duties or is associated with muscle weakness, because it is almost impossible to get SSDI due to pain. Also, never mention depression, anxiety or medications you take for them unless these symptoms prevent you from working. Depression is an automatic rejection unless you live in a mental hospital.
In the "Remarks" section at the end of the application, briefly summarize your answers and describe your work disability as caused by your specific PPS symptoms, again linking each work limitation to a given symptom and using the wording in they Ruling. Also, mention long-standing polio "disabilities" that are not problems. SSA decides that you are work disabled based on your age, levels of skill and schooling. If you load trucks and graduated from the 8th grade, SSA won't expect you to go to college to get "sedentary" career. But, if your are a college grad and have trouble walking, SSA will say you have the education and skills to do something that doesn't require walking. Some people with severe fatigue, but who have always used a leg brace, have been denied SSDI because SSA said, " Your leg has always been paralyzed and should not affect your working at a desk job." You should say something like, "The fact that I have always used a long leg brace and that my arm has always been weak has nothing to do with my disabling post-polio fatigue today."
The Ruling states that polio survivors' description of symptoms and limitations to their own physicians and psychologists are the primary factors when it comes diagnosing PPS and inability to work. An EMG and functional capacity evaluation have been removed from the evaluation process for PPS. The Ruling also states that only in "select cases, where severity of the impairment is unclear, an examination by a physician or psychologist who is knowledgeable about polio and postpolio sequelae is appropriate, if such a specialist is available." SSA can ask for what's called a "Consultative Examination" if there is not enough information in you're doctor's reports to determine if you are work disabled. However, many polio survivors find SSA sending them for a consultative examination to a neurologist -- or even a psychiatrist -- who knows nothing about PPS. SSA policy states that your treating doctor is the "preferred source" for the consultative examination, unless your doctor's records contain "conflicts or inconsistencies" or "prior experience indicates that the treating (doctor) is not a productive source of clear information." You have the right, and SSA regulations require, that you to go back to your own doctor for a consultative examination.
You took the time to vote, so put that vote to use. SSA gets very careful when they know your Senators and Congressperson are watching over their shoulder. Send a letter like this and attach the Social Security Ruling:

Since it's the government mistakes do happen and you may get denied. If you are denied, read the reason for denial, which may be because of the adjudicator's not having read or misreading the Social Security Ruling. Find out the specific reason for the denial. Then do two things. FIRST, ask your Congressperson and Senators to ask for an Administrative Review of your denial to determine if the guidelines in the Social Security Ruling were followed and the latest policies about PPS were applied. Write your Senators and Congressperson: